64 Annual Report Governance
Key Audit Matter How our scope addressed the matter
In responding to the key audit matter, we
performed the following audit procedures:
• assessed whether the Company’s accounting
policy for investments is in accordance with
relevant accounting standards and the AIC
SORP, and tested whether management have
valued the investments in accordance with that
policy;
• confirmed the existence and ownership of all
investments by agreeing the holdings listed in
the portfolio at year end to an independent
confirmation we received directly from the
Company’s custodian;
• examined the independent service auditor’s
assurance report on the custodian’s controls
over assets under its custody;
• independently priced 100% of the quoted
equity portfolio by obtaining the bid prices from
independent market sources and calculating the
total valuation based on Company investment
holdings, which was agreed to the financial
statements;
• assessed the valuation of the Company’s
unquoted investment in Phoenix SG Limited by
examining the valuation report prepared by
management’s expert as at 26 January 2022
and examining management’s assessment of
its valuation at 31 December 2021. This
included engaging our valuation specialists to
evaluate the adequacy of assumptions made by
management’s expert and enabled us to
challenge the assumptions made by
management. We also obtained Phoenix SG
Limited’s audited financial statements for the
year ended 31 December 2021 and
recomputed the Company’s proportionate share
of the net assets;
• agreed the Company’s holding in Phoenix SG
Limited at the year end to a confirmation from
the Company’s custodian;
• substantively agreed a sample of additions and
disposals of investments during the year by
agreeing to trade confirmations, agreements
and bank statements, as applicable; and
• examined the book cost reconciliation prepared
by management for accuracy and consistency
with the results of other substantive audit
procedures performed on investments.
Valuation and existence of investments measured
at fair value through profit or loss
We identified the valuation and existence of
investments measured at fair value through
profit or loss as a significant risk, which was
one of the most significant assessed risks of
material misstatement due to error.
The Company’s principal investment
objective is to provide shareholders with long
term returns through capital and income
growth by investing in a concentrated portfolio
of UK equities.
The investment portfolio, at £186,637,000
(2020: £157,894,000), is the largest balance on
the statement of financial position at the year
end and the main driver of the Company’s
performance. Included within this is the
Company’s investment in Phoenix SG Limited
amounting to £3,400,000 (2000: £8,066,000).
This is a level 3 investment and its valuation is
based on unobservable inputs and is carried
out by a third party valuer.
Incorrect asset pricing or failure to maintain
proper legal title of the investments held by the
Company could have an impact on the portfolio
valuation and therefore, the return generated
for Shareholders.
Our results
Our audit testing did not identify any material
misstatements in the valuation of the
Company’s investment portfolio as at the year-
end or any material misstatements with regards
to the existence of the underlying investments
at the year-end.
Relevant disclosures in the Annual Report 2021
• Financial statements: accounting policy, note
1c ‘Investments’; and note 2 ‘Investments
held at fair value through profit or loss’; and
• Audit Committee Report: ‘Valuation of
investments’, page 58.